Windsor Commons Apartments Austin Review: New Construction Near Mueller, But Read the Fine Print

Windsor Commons keeps showing up when people search for newer apartments near Mueller. The math looks good at first: 2024 construction, 2 months free rent, and a Windsor Park address that puts you close to Mueller without paying Mueller prices. I track pricing and screening criteria across 1,000+ Austin apartment communities (TX license #679806), and this property caught my eye because the numbers don’t add up the way the listing suggests.

Here’s what listing sites won’t tell you: Greystar uses a “Total Monthly Leasing Price” model at this property. The base rent you see on Apartments.com or Zillow? It doesn’t include mandatory monthly fees that get added to every lease. Once you add those required charges and the bundled WireStar internet (which you can’t opt out of), your actual monthly cost is higher than what shows up on the listing.

I’m going to break down the real numbers, the screening situation, and what 180+ resident reviews say about living here after the leasing tour ends.

Quick Facts

That 4.7 Google rating is high, but context matters. Most of those 98 reviews are from people who toured the property and loved the leasing staff. Reviews from people who’ve actually lived here for months tell a different story. I’ll get into those further down.

Best For / Skip If

Best For

You work from home and want to be near Mueller without paying Mueller prices. AMLI North Park about a mile away starts at $1,792. Solomon, about three quarters of a mile south, starts at $1,311 but was built in 2023. Windsor Commons offers 2024 construction with 2 months free, which drops net effective rent on a 1BR to around $1,602. That’s competitive for new construction in this part of East Austin, and the coworking space and lounge areas give you somewhere to work besides your kitchen counter. Just know the internet situation has issues (more on that below).

You have a larger dog. No weight limit on pets is genuinely rare in Austin. Most newer communities cap at 50 to 75 pounds. Windsor Commons charges a one time $300 pet fee (you don’t get it back) and $25 per month in pet rent, which is about what most newer Austin apartments charge. Breed restrictions still apply (no Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, Akitas, Chows, Cane Corsos, or Dobermans), but if your dog is heavy and not on the restricted list, this property works. For more options, check out our guide to Austin apartments that accept large dogs.

You qualify for income restricted housing. Windsor Commons has SMART Housing units set aside for people who make under a certain income. Single person? Cap is $56,220 annually. These units start at $1,296 for a studio, and you get the same finishes and amenities as market rate units. No separate building. No different entrance. If you qualify, this is one of the better SMART Housing options in Austin right now.

You want new construction with minimal maintenance headaches. Everything in the building is less than two years old. Appliances are new, the HVAC system is new, plumbing hasn’t had time to develop issues. Reviews back this up: the maintenance team is responsive and handles requests quickly. That reliability matters more than most people realize until something breaks at 11 PM on a Friday.

Skip If

Reliable internet is critical for your job. WireStar is the mandatory internet provider here, and people keep saying the speeds are inconsistent, especially with multiple devices connected. One person flat out warned remote workers to stay away from this property because of the internet. You can’t choose your own provider. It’s bundled in. If your income depends on stable video calls and fast uploads, test the connection before you sign.

You’re sensitive to noise from neighbors. The walls and ceilings are thinner than you’d expect for 2024 construction. One resident says they hear every footstep from upstairs, including pets walking around, and can overhear conversations through the walls. This is not a 1970s wood frame building. It’s new construction that apparently cut corners on soundproofing.

You don’t want to pay $200 to find out if you’re approved. The $200 application fee per applicant is among the highest in Austin. Most communities charge $50 to $75. Greystar uses Rentgrow for screening, and at least one person says it felt like an automatic denial with no real explanation. That’s $200 gone with nothing to show for it.

Wondering if Windsor Commons fits your situation?

Fill out a quick form and I’ll reach out to go over your specifics: income, credit, pets, timeline. I can check whether you’ll likely qualify before you spend $200 on an application, and I’ll share any current specials that might not be listed online. You’ll hear from a real person (me), not an automated system.

Get Started Here

Location Deep Dive

What’s Actually Nearby

Windsor Commons sits in the Windsor Park neighborhood, tucked behind Hank’s Austin (a restaurant, bar, and coffee shop that’s practically attached to the complex). That’s your closest hangout spot, and people who live here love having it right there.

For groceries, H-E-B on East 51st and I-35 is about a 5 minute drive (1.5 miles). CVS is within walking distance. Little Deli has a location right in the Windsor Park neighborhood on Briarcliff Blvd, less than half a mile away. Mueller Lake Park is less than a mile south, with trails, a playground, and green space.

Schools are Austin ISD. Harris Elementary is 0.2 miles away. Webb Middle School and Northeast Early College High School cover this address. Highland Station on the MetroRail Red Line is 2.6 miles west, giving you rail access to downtown and North Austin.

This is not a fully walkable neighborhood. You’ll drive for most errands beyond Hank’s and CVS. But you’re close enough to Mueller’s shops and restaurants to feel connected without paying Mueller rents.

The Commute Math

Route note: You’ll use Cameron Road south to get downtown, or hop on I-35 which is about a mile west. I-35 rush hour traffic heading downtown is brutal between 7:30 and 9 AM. If you’re taking I-35 south during peak hours, add 15 to 20 minutes to whatever Google Maps tells you. For East Austin employers and UT, you’ve got a short, mostly surface street commute that stays reasonable.

Neighborhood Vibe

Windsor Park is changing. It used to be all modest ranch homes from the 1950s and 1960s, and Windsor Commons is part of the newer development reshaping this stretch. The area is quiet and residential. It’s not trendy East Austin with street art and converted warehouse bars. It’s not Mueller’s planned walkable grid either. It sits between those two worlds, and some people like that middle ground. The East Austin apartment guide covers how the different pockets of East Austin compare.

Pricing and True Cost

Floor Plans

*Net effective rent calculated with 2 months free on a 12 month lease. See math below.

One thing to watch on the washer/dryer situation: “Supplied” means the unit includes a washer and dryer. “Connection” means you get hookups but need to buy or rent your own machines. That’s a real cost difference. If a unit shows “Connection,” budget an extra $50 to $80 per month for washer/dryer rental, or $800 to $1,200 upfront to buy your own set. About half the floor plans here are connection only.

Net Effective Rent Calculation

Current special: 2 months free on a 12 month lease.

Using the daily multiplier method (Austin market standard):

• 2 months free = 60 days
• 12 month lease = 365 days
• Multiplier = (365 – 60) / 365 = 0.8356

For a 1BR A6 at $1,917/month: $1,917 x 0.8356 = $1,602/month net effective Monthly savings: $1,917 – $1,602 = $315/month Total savings over the lease: $315 x 12 = $3,780

For a Studio S1 at $1,577/month: $1,577 x 0.8356 = $1,318/month net effective

For a 2BR B1 at $2,578/month: $2,578 x 0.8356 = $2,154/month net effective

Those net effective numbers look solid for 2024 construction near Mueller. But here’s the thing: the base rent doesn’t include the mandatory monthly charges.

All the Fees

No admin fee. Most Austin properties charge $150 to $350, so that’s real money you’re keeping on move in.

But the mandatory monthly fees add up fast. WireStar internet ($65), valet trash ($30 + $3 admin), and renters liability ($14.50) stack about $112/month on top of base rent before you add parking or pets. One resident put it bluntly in their review: they asked the property to end their WireStar contract because “for $65, the internet is too poor.” You can’t choose your own provider.

Early lease termination costs 200% of base rent. That’s among the steepest penalties in Austin. On a 1BR at $1,917, breaking early means owing $3,834. Know that going in.

True Monthly Cost (Realistic Scenario)

1BR A6 unit, one dog, garage parking:

• Net effective rent: $1,602
• Valet trash + admin: $33
• WireStar internet/cable: $65
• Renters liability: $14.50
• Pet rent: $25
• Garage parking: $20
• True monthly cost: ~$1,760

Without the special (renewal pricing): $1,917 + $33 + $65 + $14.50 + $25 + $20 = $2,075/month

That $315/month difference between year one and renewal pricing is worth thinking about before you sign. Specials change. What’s listed above was accurate as of July 2026, but I talk to leasing teams weekly, and offers shift.

Want to know what specials are actually available right now?

I track live pricing at Windsor Commons and 1,000+ other Austin communities. Fill out the form and I’ll send you the current deal, check whether the unit you want actually gets the special, and calculate your true monthly cost with all the fees.

Get Current Specials

Screening Criteria

Income Requirement

Windsor Commons requires 3x monthly rent in gross income. That’s confirmed in Greystar’s paperwork and matches what I see across their other Austin properties. Here’s what that looks like:

For the income restricted SMART Housing units, there’s an income ceiling instead of a floor. A single person household can earn no more than $56,220 annually. A two person household caps at $64,260. You’ll need documents showing you’re under the cap.

Credit Expectations

Windsor Commons doesn’t publish a credit score minimum. That’s standard for Greystar. Their screening runs through a third party that scores you pass or fail with no specific number attached. If you don’t pass, you’re looking at a higher deposit, needing a guarantor, or getting denied.

Based on how this plays out at other Greystar Austin properties, here’s what I’d expect:

650+ credit: Smooth approval with standard deposit. You should have no issues.

600-649 credit: You’ll probably get approved, but expect a higher deposit or a monthly credit premium of $50 to $100. At other Greystar properties, that premium hits every month for the life of your lease. It’s not a one time fee.

Below 600 credit: It gets uncertain. Newer Greystar builds like this tend to be stricter than the average Austin apartment at this price point. One resident says it felt like an automatic denial through Rentgrow with barely any explanation.

What Gets You Denied

Let me be direct about what gets you denied at a Greystar property like this:

• Active property debt to a previous landlord
• Eviction judgment within the past 5 to 7 years
• Recent felony conviction
• Not enough income proof (paystubs, tax returns, offer letter)
• Getting flagged by Rentgrow screening (which checks credit, criminal, and rental history all at once)

Application Process

1. Apply online. $200 per applicant. You don’t get it back if you’re denied.
2. Rentgrow screens credit, criminal background, and rental history.
3. Approval or denial, usually within 2 to 3 business days.
4. If approved, you’ll have a short window to sign your lease before they release the unit.

If you’re working with me, I need to register you by email before you tour. That’s how Greystar tracks referrals here.

What a Locator Can Do at This Property

Here’s what separates working with a locator from applying blind: I can tell you whether you’re likely to qualify before you spend $200 finding out. If Windsor Commons looks tight for your situation, I know which nearby properties have more flexibility. I work with properties across East Austin that range from strict screening to more flexible options.

Resident Reviews Decoded

Listing sites show you a 4.7 Google rating and call it a day. That number? It needs context. I went through every review I could find: Google, ModernMsg, Apartments.com, ApartmentHomeLiving, RentCafe, and a few others. That’s 180+ reviews total.

Review Pattern Analysis

What Residents Consistently Praise

Tyler, Colten (also spelled Colton), Faith, Kassidy, and Ty all get called out by name across dozens of reviews. More than at any other property I’ve reviewed recently. This isn’t generic “staff is nice” feedback. People mention specific things: Tyler helping someone find a unit that fit their budget, Colten squeezing in a last minute tour for a visitor who flew in from out of town, Faith walking people through paperwork without rushing them. That kind of named praise across 180+ reviews tells you something real about this leasing team.

Cleanliness, modern finishes, and the amenity spaces all show up positively. The pool, gym, and coworking area get regular compliments. A lot of people say it’s quiet, which makes the noise complaints from a few others stand out. Your experience probably depends on which unit and floor you land on. And community events like movie nights and holiday parties get mentioned positively by residents who’ve been here longer.

What Residents Consistently Criticize

Internet is the complaint that comes up the most. WireStar provides the mandatory bundled internet, and people keep saying the connections are spotty, especially with multiple devices. The building markets coworking lounges and fiber optic on its amenity list. The actual performance doesn’t match.

Then there’s ButterflyMX, the building’s smart access system. It’s caused problems with packages and guest access. People say delivery drivers can’t get into the building, and the app doesn’t work reliably. Management says they’re aware and working on it, but these complaints go back months.

Move-in readiness is another sore spot. A few people showed up to units that weren’t fully ready: water valves not turned on, apartments not cleaned, minor fixes needed on day one. For a property less than two years old, that tells you something about how they’re getting units ready between tenants.

How Management Responds

Greystar’s leasing team responds to nearly every review, positive and negative. And the responses are mostly personalized, not generic templates. When residents bring up specific problems, management talks about what they’re doing to fix it. That’s better than what I see at most properties. It won’t solve your internet speed, but it tells you complaints will at least get heard.

The Uncomfortable Truth

No listing site will write this section. I’m not trying to kill the deal. I just want you to know exactly what you’re signing up for.

The “Total Monthly Pricing” Model Hides Your Real Cost

Greystar’s own fine print says it plainly: “Pricing shown does not reflect the total monthly leasing price.” The base rent you see on listing sites doesn’t include the mandatory fees that get stacked on top. WireStar internet costs $65. Valet trash and its admin fee add $33. Renters liability insurance adds $14.50. That’s $112.50/month in required charges before parking or pets.

On a 1BR listed at $1,917 base rent, you’re actually paying closer to $2,030 before optional add-ons. When one prospective renter questioned the bundled internet charge, management called it “transparency.” But transparency would mean showing the total price upfront, not burying it in fine print. Add at least $112 to any base rent you see for Windsor Commons before you start comparing it to other places.

New Construction Doesn’t Mean Good Soundproofing

One ModernMsg reviewer described the walls and ceilings as “ridiculously thin.” Every footstep from upstairs. Pets walking around. Conversations through the walls. Another resident mentioned a loud neighbor above and bright exterior lights.

For a building completed in 2024, that’s disappointing. You’d expect better noise blocking between units in new construction, but a lot of modern mid-rise buildings use lightweight framing that saves money at the expense of keeping your neighbor’s noise out of your apartment. If you’re a light sleeper or work from home taking calls, ask to tour a unit on a floor and location similar to what you’d actually rent. Visit when other residents are home so you can hear what it’s really like.

That $200 Application Fee Is a Risk

At $200 per applicant, Windsor Commons charges 2.5 to 4 times what most Austin apartments charge. Two people applying together? That’s $400 before you know if you’re approved. Greystar uses Rentgrow for screening, and at least one person says it felt like an automatic denial with no real explanation. You don’t get that money back. If there’s any uncertainty about your credit, rental history, or income paperwork, spending $200 to find out is a gamble. This is exactly the situation where talking to a locator first saves real money.

Ready to move forward, or want to explore alternatives?

You’ve seen the full picture now. If Windsor Commons fits, great. If the internet issues, pricing model, or application fee give you pause, I work with dozens of East Austin communities. I can point you to places that fit better.

Let’s Talk Options

FAQ

What credit score do I need for Windsor Commons?

Windsor Commons doesn’t publish a credit score minimum. Greystar’s screening runs a pass/fail with no specific number. Based on what I see at similar Greystar properties, I’d expect 650+ credit for smooth approval. Below 600, your chances drop and you may face a monthly credit premium or denial.

What utilities are included at Windsor Commons?

Water is included in rent. WireStar internet and cable are mandatory at $65/month. Valet trash is $30/month plus a $3/month admin fee. Renters liability insurance is $14.50/month if you go with the property’s option, or you can bring your own policy. Electricity is on you, through Austin Energy.

Does Windsor Commons have income restricted apartments?

Yes. Windsor Commons is a mixed income community with SMART Housing units at 60% of area median income. A one person household can earn up to $56,220 annually to qualify. These units have the same finishes and amenities as market rate units.

What is parking like at Windsor Commons?

You get surface lot parking included. Garage spaces are $20/month. Reserved spots run $75/month. Parking is tight, and some buildings are a longer walk from the garage than you’d like.

Is Windsor Commons good for remote workers?

It depends on your internet needs. The coworking space and lounges are solid for working from home, and the community is quiet during the day. But WireStar internet gets consistent complaints about spotty speeds with multiple devices. If video calls and reliable uploads are critical, test the connection before committing. Check our guide on the best neighborhoods for young professionals in Austin for more options that work for remote workers.

How much is the application fee?

$200 per applicant, and you won’t get it back if denied. That’s way higher than the Austin average of $50 to $75. If two people apply together, budget $400 total.

What are the biggest complaints about Windsor Commons?

The WireStar internet is spotty and you can’t switch providers. Walls and ceilings let noise through between units. The ButterflyMX access system causes package delivery headaches. And the $200 application fee stings. The building and staff get consistent praise, but these everyday issues come up across multiple platforms.

When was Windsor Commons built?

2024. It’s a 404 unit mid-rise managed by Greystar, with 3 to 5 story buildings.

The Bottom Line: Is Windsor Commons Worth It?

Windsor Commons offers real strengths. It’s 2024 construction near Mueller at prices that undercut its immediate neighbors, with a leasing team that stands out in resident reviews. The 2 months free special drops net effective rent to around $1,318 for a studio and $1,602 for a one bedroom. No weight limit on pets, SMART Housing units for lower income renters. You won’t find those at most places nearby. The maintenance team responds quickly, the community stays quiet, and the building is clean.

The catch is the stuff that doesn’t show up in listing photos. Mandatory monthly fees ($112+ between valet trash, WireStar, and insurance) push your real cost way past the advertised base rent. The soundproofing between units is weak for new construction. The $200 application fee is a barrier. And early lease termination at 200% of base rent means once you sign, you’re locked in.

This property makes sense if: you want new construction near Mueller, you have a larger dog, you qualify for SMART Housing, or you value responsive maintenance over internet speed.

This property doesn’t make sense if: your income depends on reliable internet, you’re sensitive to neighbor noise, your application has credit concerns (at $200 per try, guessing is expensive), or you want control over your internet provider.

The first year math works. Net effective rent of $1,602 for a one bedroom with 2024 finishes is real value. Just know your true monthly cost after mandatory fees is closer to $1,715 without pets or parking, and plan for renewal pricing that will look very different from year one.

If you want help figuring out whether Windsor Commons fits your situation, or you’d rather find something similar without the internet headaches, fill out the form. I’ll text you within a few hours.

Need Help?

You’ve got everything you need to make a decision on Windsor Commons. But if you want help:

Fill out the form above and I’ll text you to answer questions, check your approval odds, share current specials, and help with next steps. You’ll talk to me directly. My service is free.

Going solo? Just tell them “Ross Quade from Austin Apartment Team” referred you on your tour and application. Text me at 512-360-0852 when you apply so I can make sure everything’s on track.