12 Weeks Free Sounds Great — Until You Do the Math on Fees For Rent

  • $1335-$2340

The Fenley Apartments Austin Review: Brand-New 2026 South Austin Construction on Menchaca Road for Rent


A brand-new property just opened on Menchaca Road with 2.5 months free rent, no pet weight limit, and 240 units that didn’t exist six months ago. So I’m going to answer the question you actually came here with: is The Fenley worth signing a lease at a place with zero track record?

I track Austin apartment pricing across 1,000+ properties daily through my listing data and property managers I talk to. As a licensed Texas real estate agent (License #679806), I’ve watched enough new buildings fill up to know that the first six months tell you almost everything about how a property will run. The Fenley is in that window right now.

Here’s what the listing sites won’t tell you: a 5.0 Google rating based on two reviews means nothing. The 2.5-month concession is real, but the net effective math depends on which floor plan you pick. And RangeWater, the management company, is running seven Austin-area projects at the same time. Whether that means a well-run operation or a stretched thin staff is the question nobody can answer yet.

Let me show you what I mean.


Quick Facts: The Fenley at a Glance

Field Details
Address 11800 Menchaca Rd, Austin, TX 78748
Year Built 2026 (brand new)
Total Units 240 units, 3 stories
Management RangeWater Real Estate
Rent Range $1,335 – $2,340/mo (as of September 2026)
Current Special 2.5 months free on 12-month lease
Income Requirement 3x rent (standard for new construction; confirm with property)
Pet Policy 2 pets max, no weight limit, breed restrictions apply, $400 non-refundable fee + $30/mo pet rent per pet
Application Fee $60 per person
Admin Fee $150
Security Deposit $350
Google Rating 5.0 (2 reviews)
Website livethefenley.com
Phone (512) 547-1176

The 5.0 Google rating comes from exactly two reviews. Both are five stars. One has actual text, one is just a rating. That’s not a reputation. That’s a starting point. I’ll get into what you should be watching for instead of relying on a number that could flip with the next three reviewers.


Best For / Skip If

Who This Property Works For

You want brand-new everything and don’t want to pay top dollar for a building that’s already five or ten years old. The Fenley opened in 2026 with quartz counters, hardwood-style flooring, stainless steel appliances, tile backsplashes, and in-home washers and dryers. You’re the first person to use the appliances, the first to run water through the pipes, the first to find out if the AC keeps up in August. That’s either exciting or terrifying depending on your personality. But if it matters to you, this is one of the few options in South Austin where you can get new construction at a one bedroom starting around $1,435 before the concession.

You have pets that get rejected everywhere else. No weight limit. Two pets allowed. That puts The Fenley in a small group of Austin properties where your 90-pound dog doesn’t automatically disqualify you.

The breed restriction list is long though: Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Dobermans, Mastiffs, Chows, Akitas, Malamutes, and about 15 other breeds are banned (mixed breeds with those bloodlines too). Pets must be spayed or neutered, and a pet screening is required before move in. But if your dog isn’t on that list, the no weight limit makes this one of the more flexible options in South Austin. If you’re navigating pet restrictions across Austin, an apartment locator can help you find the right fit.

You’re motivated by the concession math. 2.5 months free on a 12-month lease drops a $1,435 one bedroom to roughly $1,140/month net effective. That saves you close to $300/month off the listed rent. I’ll break down the full calculation in the pricing section below.

Who Should Probably Skip It

You need a proven track record before you sign. Two Google reviews. Zero ApartmentRatings reviews. No Yelp presence. No history to check on maintenance response times, management communication, or how they handle lease renewals. If you’re the kind of renter who reads 50 reviews before making a decision, there’s nothing to read yet.

You need public transit access. Menchaca Road at this stretch is car territory. Capital Metro runs limited service in the area, and the closest grocery run will involve a car. If you work downtown and don’t drive, this isn’t the commute you want.

You’re worried about lease-up noise and construction. New properties in their first year often have finish work still happening, landscaping going in, and new residents moving in on different schedules. Expect some disruption until the place settles in.


Ready to See If The Fenley Fits Your Situation?

I can tell you whether you’d get approved here before you spend the $60 application fee. If this place doesn’t work out, I know which nearby properties will.


Location Deep Dive

What’s Actually Nearby

The Fenley sits on Menchaca Road south of Slaughter Lane in the 78748 zip code. Deep South Austin. Past Westgate and Garrison Park, in a stretch that’s been filling in with new apartments and houses for the last five years.

Grocery: The nearest H-E-B is the Slaughter Lane location about 1.5 miles north, a 5-minute drive. There’s a Walmart Supercenter at Southpark Meadows roughly 2.5 miles south. For a quick grab, you’ll find convenience stores within a mile, but a full grocery trip means getting in your car.

Dining is thinner at this stretch of Menchaca compared to the South Lamar or South Congress corridors, but you’re not totally stranded. Texican Cafe is practically next door at 11940 Menchaca, and Southpark Meadows is a short drive south with chain restaurants and fast food. Head north toward William Cannon and Brodie Lane for more sit-down variety. Coffee-wise, you’re driving to get a good cup.

Parks and outdoors: Mary Moore Searight Metropolitan Park is about 2 miles south and has trails, sports fields, a disc golf course, and a dog park. Slaughter Creek Trail runs nearby for jogging and cycling. The greenbelt access that makes central South Austin popular is farther north, but you’re not short on outdoor space.

Commute Math

Destination Off-Peak Rush Hour
Downtown Austin (Congress & 6th) ~20 min 35-50 min
Austin-Bergstrom Airport ~20 min 25-30 min
The Domain ~30 min 45-55 min
St. David’s South Austin Medical Center ~10 min 12-15 min
Southpark Meadows Shopping ~5 min 8-10 min

The I-35 commute north is the painful one. Morning rush toward downtown can stretch past 45 minutes depending on where you merge. Mopac (Loop 1) is the alternative, but access from Menchaca requires cutting over on Slaughter Lane or William Cannon, which adds its own traffic. If you work south of the river or near the airport, this spot works well. If you’re driving to north Austin or The Domain every day, not so much.

Neighborhood Vibe

This part of South Austin has a different character from the popular SoCo or South Lamar areas that people picture when they hear “South Austin.” Quieter. More suburban. Newer neighborhoods mixed in with scattered older properties. Menchaca Road has small businesses, churches, and houses lining both sides. It’s not walkable the way the South Austin neighborhoods closer to downtown are, but it’s also less congested and less expensive.

Here’s the trade-off: you give up walkability and nightlife access for newer construction, more space for your money, and less noise. That swap makes sense for a lot of renters, but you need to know going in that this isn’t the “Keep Austin Weird” part of town. It’s the “come home, park, and relax” part.

Schools in the area are Austin ISD: Menchaca Elementary, Paredes Middle School, and Akins High School.


Pricing and True Cost

Floor Plan Breakdown

Bed/Bath Sq Ft Base Rent Net Effective (2.5 Mo Free) Notes
Studio / 1 BA 549 $1,335 $1,061 Smallest layout
1 BR / 1 BA 691 $1,435 $1,140 Smallest one bedroom
1 BR / 1 BA 745 $1,475 $1,172 Mid-size one bedroom
1 BR / 1 BA 790 $1,535 $1,220 Largest one bedroom
2 BR / 2 BA 1,074 $2,065 $1,641 Entry two bedroom
2 BR / 2 BA 1,126 $2,095 $1,664 Mid-size two bedroom
2 BR / 2 BA 1,175 $2,150 $1,708 Large two bedroom
2 BR / 2 BA 1,180 $2,340 $1,859 Premium two bedroom

All layouts are flats with in-home washer and dryer. No lofts or townhomes here.

Net Effective Rent: The Real Math

The Fenley is running 2.5 months free on a 12-month lease. That’s a big concession. Most listing sites don’t show you what it actually means for your monthly payment, so here’s the math on the 1BR/1BA at 691 square feet:

  • Base rent: $1,435/month
  • Lease term: 12 months (365 days)
  • Free rent: 2.5 months (75 days)
  • Daily multiplier: (365 – 75) / 365 = 0.7945
  • Net effective rent: $1,435 x 0.7945 = $1,140/month
  • Monthly savings: $1,435 – $1,140 = $295/month
  • Total savings over the lease: $3,587

That $1,140 net effective for a new one bedroom in South Austin holds up. For context, Menchaca Commons (built 2022, 0.3 miles away) starts at $1,400 and isn’t running a deal like that. La Madrid (built 2018, 0.6 miles away) starts at $1,099 but is eight years older with fewer amenities.

The catch: when your lease renews after 12 months, expect the base rent to apply. That $1,140 becomes $1,435 or possibly higher if they’ve raised rates. Build that into your budget from day one.

Fee Breakdown

Required Fees (Everyone Pays)

Fee Amount
Application fee $60 per person, non-refundable
Admin fee $150, one-time
Security deposit $350

Optional Fees (If These Apply)

Fee Amount
Pet fee (non-refundable) $400 per pet
Pet rent $30/month per pet
Parking Available (carport and surface); pricing not published. Ask during tour

True Monthly Cost: A Real Scenario

Here’s what you’d actually pay each month in the 691 sq ft one bedroom with one pet, using the concession rate:

  • Net effective rent: $1,140
  • Pet rent (1 pet): $30
  • Renter’s insurance (estimate): $15
  • True monthly cost: ~$1,185/month

When you renew and the free rent goes away, that jumps to:

  • Base rent: $1,435
  • Pet rent: $30
  • Renter’s insurance: $15
  • True monthly cost: ~$1,480/month

That’s a $295/month increase at renewal. Plan for it.


Want to Compare This Property’s True Cost to Nearby Options?

I do this same math on every property I work with. If you want to see how The Fenley stacks up against two or three other South Austin options at your budget, I can line them up for you.


Screening Criteria

Heads up: The Fenley hasn’t published its screening criteria anywhere. The thresholds below are based on what’s typical for new construction managed by companies like RangeWater. Confirm all screening details directly with the property at (512) 547-1176 before applying.

Income Requirements

Unit Type Base Rent Monthly Income Needed (3x) Annual Income Hourly Wage (40 hrs)
Studio $1,335 $4,005 $48,060 $23.11
1 BR (691 sqft) $1,435 $4,305 $51,660 $24.84
1 BR (790 sqft) $1,535 $4,605 $55,260 $26.57
2 BR (1,074 sqft) $2,065 $6,195 $74,340 $35.74

That’s based on 3x rent, which is standard for new construction in Austin. If The Fenley uses a different number, the math changes. Confirm with the property.

What Likely Gets You Approved

New construction managed by companies like RangeWater usually screens through automated systems. Credit scores of 650+ usually get approved without issues at these properties. Between 600 and 649, you’re probably looking at a higher deposit or a cosigner. Below 550, expect a denial at most places like this. The Fenley hasn’t published its own cutoffs, so call and ask before you apply.

What Likely Gets You Denied

Based on how properties like this usually screen:

  • Active property debt owed to a previous landlord (this is almost always an auto-decline)
  • Recent eviction filings (new construction rarely works with evictions, so call to ask about their specific lookback)
  • Not enough verifiable income
  • Lying on the application

Application Process

  1. Turn in your application with the $60 fee (you don’t get this back)
  2. Property runs credit, background, and rental history checks
  3. You’ll usually hear back in 2-3 business days
  4. If approved, pay the $150 admin fee and security deposit to secure your unit

Here’s what working with a locator does for you here: I can tell you whether your income, credit, and rental history would pass The Fenley’s screening before you spend $60 finding out. If The Fenley looks tight for your situation, I know which South Austin properties have more flexibility. Reach out at 512-865-4672.


What to Watch For (Instead of Reviews)

The Fenley opened in 2026 and has two Google reviews as of September 2026. I went through every other review platform I could find: ApartmentRatings, Yelp, RentCafe, VeryApt, ModernMsg, ApartmentList, Apartments.com, Birdeye, HotPads, ForRent. Nothing. Zero reviews across all of them.

Fair warning: there’s a different Fenley property in Bloomington, Minnesota with 80+ reviews. Completely different building, different management company. Don’t mix them up.

Two reviews isn’t enough to see any patterns. Instead of a regular review section, here’s what I’d tell any client to watch for in the first year of a new property:

Management Response Speed

One of the two Google reviews mentions staff members by name: Jessica (manager) and Christina (touring). RangeWater’s corporate response to both reviews came within days, which is a good early sign. But the real test is maintenance. How quickly do they respond to a work order at 9pm on a Friday? Nobody knows yet.

RangeWater manages roughly 1,600 units across the Austin area. Thousands more nationally. They’re a big company with set systems for handling things, which usually means they’re decent at keeping track when you put in a request. The flip side? The team on site might be thin while the building is still filling up.

The Stuff That Needs Fixing

New buildings almost always have things that need fixing in the first six months: cabinet doors that don’t close right, grout that needs touching up, AC that needs dialing in, appliances that aren’t working right. This is normal and not a dealbreaker. What matters is how fast the maintenance team gets to these things.

Before you sign, ask the leasing office: How many units are leased right now? How many maintenance people do you have on site? How long does a regular maintenance request take?

Landscaping and Common Areas

The pool, dog park, hammock courtyard, garden room, and outdoor fireplaces are all on the amenity list. Ask during your tour which ones are actually open and ready to use versus “coming soon.” New properties sometimes start leasing before every amenity is finished.


The Uncomfortable Truth

No listing site will write this section. I’m not trying to talk you out of The Fenley. But you need the full picture before you sign a yearlong lease.

You’re the Guinea Pig

There’s no polite way to say it. The first residents at any new construction property are beta testers. You’ll find the plumbing quirks, how much noise carries between apartments, the parking lot problems, and what’s missing or not finished before anyone else does. The leasing team won’t know the answers to half your questions because they haven’t been through a full year of residents yet.

This isn’t a reason to avoid The Fenley. But go in with your eyes open. Take photos of everything when you move in. Send maintenance requests in writing through the portal so there’s a record.

The Renewal Cliff Is Real

That 2.5 months free concession saves you roughly $3,587 over 12 months on a one bedroom at $1,435. When your lease renews, you’re looking at full price or close to it. If rents hold where they are, that’s a $295/month jump. If The Fenley raises base rent at renewal (which new properties frequently do once they fill up), the gap gets wider.

Ask the leasing team directly: what were your renewal terms for the first round of residents? If they can’t answer yet, that’s fine, but build the full base rent into your budget.

No Track Record With RangeWater at This Address

RangeWater has other Austin-area properties, but this is a new site with a new team. And here’s the thing about management companies: the name on the building matters less than the people inside it. The leasing manager, the maintenance crew, the community manager. Those are the people who shape your daily experience, and at The Fenley, they’re all brand new to this building.


Ready to Move Forward, or Want to See Alternatives?

If The Fenley looks like a fit, I can walk you through the application process and what to expect. If you want to compare it to two or three other South Austin options at a similar price point, I do that for free.


FAQ

Does The Fenley accept dogs with no weight limit?

Yes. The Fenley allows up to 2 pets with no weight limit. Breed restrictions apply, and a pet screening is required. Each pet costs a $400 one-time fee (you won’t get it back) plus $30/month in pet rent.

What’s the cheapest apartment at The Fenley?

The studio starts at $1,335/month before the concession. With 2.5 months free on a 12-month lease, the net effective drops to about $1,061/month.

Is The Fenley in a good school district?

The Fenley falls under Austin ISD: Menchaca Elementary, Paredes Middle School, and Akins High School. Check Austin ISD’s website for current ratings and boundary maps.

Does The Fenley have in-unit washer and dryer?

Yes. Every unit includes an in-home washer and dryer, not just hookups.

How far is The Fenley from downtown Austin?

About 12 miles. Off-peak that’s around 20 minutes by car. During rush hour, expect 35 to 50 minutes heading north on I-35 or Mopac.

What’s the income requirement at The Fenley?

The standard for new construction in Austin is 3x monthly rent. The Fenley hasn’t published its exact number, so confirm at (512) 547-1176 before applying.

Are there any apartments near The Fenley?

Menchaca Commons is 0.3 miles away (built 2022, starting at $1,400). La Madrid is 0.6 miles away (built 2018, starting at $1,099). Both are on the same stretch of Menchaca Road.

Is The Fenley managed by a good company?

RangeWater Real Estate (formerly Pollack Shores/Matrix Residential) is a big national operator with roughly 1,600 units across the Austin area. They’ve been around, but the team running this specific building hasn’t been tested yet.

Can I tour The Fenley before applying?

Yeah, you can tour in person. Schedule through livethefenley.com or call (512) 547-1176.

What amenities does The Fenley have?

Pool, fitness center, hammock courtyard, outdoor fireplaces, grilling areas, coworking spaces, clubhouse, dog park, and garden room. In-unit: quartz counters, stainless steel appliances, hardwood-style flooring, in-home washer and dryer, patio or balcony in select units.


The Bottom Line

The Fenley offers something specific: new 2026 construction in South Austin with a strong concession and no weight limit on pets, which is hard to find. The net effective math is actually good. A one bedroom at $1,140/month in a building where nobody has lived before is a real value right now.

The trade-off is that you’re signing at a property with no history. No reviews to go on. No maintenance track record. No renewal data to plan around. You’re trusting that RangeWater runs a tight enough ship that the on-site team will be solid, and that the building itself will hold up the way a new building should.

This property makes sense if:

  • You want new construction and you’re comfortable being among the first residents
  • You have pets over 50 pounds that get rejected at most properties
  • You work south of the river or near the airport and don’t need walkability
  • You can budget for the base rent at renewal, not just the concession rate

This property doesn’t make sense if:

  • You need proven management and review history before committing
  • You rely on public transit for your daily commute
  • You can’t handle a $295/month increase when the concession expires
  • You want the walkable restaurant and bar scene of South Austin closer to downtown

My take: The Fenley is a solid option if the concession math works for your budget and you’re OK with the unknowns. I’d ask pointed questions during your tour. How many maintenance people do you have? Which amenities are actually done? What do renewal terms look like? If they give you straight answers, that tells you something good about how this team runs things.


Need Help?

My service is free. I’m paid a referral fee from the property’s advertising budget, so your rent is the same whether you use a locator or not.

If The Fenley looks right, I can walk you through the application and check whether you’d pass their screening so you don’t waste the $60 app fee. If it’s not the right fit, I’ll send you two or three alternatives in South Austin that match your budget and situation.

Text me at 512-360-0852.

Price:
$1335-$2340
Address:
11800 Menchaca Rd
Austin, TX 78748
Terms:
For Rent
Property Type:
Apartment
Year Built:
2026

Call 512-320-4599 for more details

Property Location