The Cheapest Central Austin Apartment — With a Catch For Rent

  • $749-$1099

Flats at Wellington Apartments Austin Review: Honest Review, True Costs, and What the 3.0 Rating Actually Means


A one bedroom in East Austin for $749 a month. A two bedroom for $799. No pet weight limit, no breed restrictions, and a month free on top of it.

I’ve been tracking rental pricing across Austin for over 14 years (TX License #679806), and numbers like that stop me in my tracks every time they pop up. Flats at Wellington sits in Windsor Park, about a mile from the Mueller development. This pocket of 78723 has gotten a lot more attention over the last few years. The price runs 20 to 30 percent less than anything nearby.

So what’s the catch?

It starts with a number: 1969.

That’s when this building went up. A 2019 renovation gave it updated finishes inside, but renovations don’t replace the bones of a building that’s been standing for over 55 years. And the Google reviews from a year ago? They paint a picture that the listing photos don’t show. Here’s what I found when I looked past the marketing.


Quick Facts

Field Details
Address 5800 Wellington Dr, Austin, TX 78723
Year Built 1969 (Renovated 2019)
Total Units 86
Management Harbor Group Management
Rent Range $749 – $1,099/month
Income Requirement 3x monthly rent
Pet Policy No weight or breed restrictions. $300 fee + $25/mo per pet. Count limit unclear (see Best For section).
Current Special 1 month free on a 12 month lease
Application Fee $50 per applicant
Admin Fee $150 (one time)
Security Deposit $500 refundable (Obligo deposit alternative available)
Google Rating 3.0 out of 5 (37 reviews)

That 3.0 Google rating jumps out. But the reviews from a year ago are harsh, and the reviews from the last few months are positive. New management is the dividing line. I’ll break that split down below.


Best For

You’re on a tight budget and need to stay near central Austin. A one bedroom at $749 base rent, in a 78723 zip code that’s a 15 minute drive from downtown, is hard to match. After the one month free special, the net effective rent drops to $687. That’s real money in a city where the average one bedroom runs over $1,400.

You have pets and you’re tired of breed restrictions. No weight limit. No breed restrictions. The $300 one time fee and $25/month pet rent per pet is standard. That combo is genuinely rare across Austin at this price point. One catch: the property listing says no pet count limit, but Harbor Group’s corporate policy caps it at 2. If you have more than two, confirm with the leasing office before applying. Check out our East Austin apartments guide for other options in the area.

You need a short lease. The minimum lease term here is 7 months. Most Austin apartments lock you into 12 to 14 months. If your timeline is uncertain or you just need a landing pad while you figure out your next move, that matters.

You’re military, a teacher, nurse, or first responder. Harbor Group runs a Hometown Hero program across all their properties, including Flats at Wellington. Show proof of current employment and they’ll waive the $50 application fee and $150 admin fee. That’s $200 you keep in your pocket at move in.

Skip If

You need laundry in your unit. Only one of the three floor plans (A1) has a washer/dryer connection in some units. The rest rely on the building’s laundry room. If in-unit laundry is on your list of things you won’t budge on, this isn’t your place.

Noise bothers you. This is a 1969 wood frame building with 86 units. Thin walls are part of the deal. Reviews mention music at all hours, and “law enforcement” is literally one of the Google review tags. The newer reviews sound better, but the building’s bones haven’t changed.

You want a pool, gym, or modern common areas. There’s no pool. No fitness center. What you get is an outdoor kitchen, a picnic area, a dog trail, and laundry rooms. That’s it. If you want a pool, a real gym, or modern shared spaces, look at the newer Mueller properties like AMLI on Aldrich or Mosaic at Mueller up the road. Our team has toured hundreds of communities and can point you to ones with the amenities you actually want.

You want screening criteria you can look up before you apply. Harbor Group uses a SafeRent Solutions risk score instead of a straight credit score cutoff. That means your approval depends on an algorithm, and it’s harder to predict where you’ll land. I’ll explain this more in the screening section.


Wondering If Flats at Wellington Fits Your Situation?

Fill out a quick form and I’ll go over your specifics: income, credit, pets, timeline. I can help you compare this property against other East Austin options before you spend $50 on an application.

Get Your Free Apartment Match →


Location Deep Dive

What’s Actually Nearby

Flats at Wellington sits on Wellington Drive in Windsor Park, between E. 51st and US-290. It’s residential. Not walkable. You’ll need a car.

Grocery: The closest H-E-B is the Mueller location at 1801 E. 51st St, about 1.5 miles south. That’s a 5 minute drive. There’s also a Fiesta Mart on Cameron Road about the same distance.

Dining: Windsor Village shopping center is about half a mile south and has a handful of options. The real food scene is on Manor Road (Dai Due, Patrizi’s, The Long Goodbye), roughly 2 miles southwest. The Mueller retail district (Torchy’s, Colleen’s Kitchen) is about 1.5 miles away.

Parks: Bartholomew District Park is less than a mile south: 57 acres, a pool, splash pad, disc golf, basketball courts, and a playground. Mueller Lake Park is about 2 miles southwest.

Transit: Highland MetroRail station is about 3 miles west. Bus routes run along Cameron Road and E. 51st. You can get downtown on the bus if you’re patient, but this isn’t a car free area.

Commute Math

Destination Distance Off Peak Rush Hour
Downtown Austin ~5 miles 12-15 min 25-40 min
UT Austin ~4.5 miles 10-14 min 20-30 min
The Domain ~9 miles 15-20 min 30-45 min
Austin-Bergstrom Airport ~13 miles 20-25 min 30-45 min
Apple (N. Austin) ~11 miles 15-20 min 35-50 min
Samsung (E. Austin) ~12 miles 15-20 min 25-35 min

Route notes: I-35 is your main corridor south to downtown, and it gets ugly during rush hour. The US-290 onramp is close, which helps for getting east toward Samsung or south toward the airport. For downtown, try Airport Blvd south to E. 7th as an alternative to I-35 when traffic is bad.

Neighborhood Vibe

Windsor Park is quiet and older. Ranch style homes from the 1950s and 60s line the surrounding streets. Not trendy. Not hip. No street art or cocktail bars around the corner. But that’s the point for a lot of my clients. It’s affordable, close to Mueller without Mueller prices, and connected to the rest of Austin by car.

The area has been changing as Mueller pulled attention east. New construction like Windsor Commons (built 2024) is going up right next door, which could affect traffic and noise during your lease. The Austin new construction pipeline is still active in this area. Something to ask about when you tour.


Pricing and True Cost

Floor Plans

Floor Plan Bed/Bath Sq Ft Base Rent Net Effective* W/D Availability
A1 1BR/1BA 712 $749 – $849 $687 – $779 Connection (select units) Available
B1 2BR/1BA 946 $799 – $899 $733 – $825 No connection Available
B2 2BR/2BA 1,007 $1,099 $1,009 No connection Unavailable

*Net effective with 1 month free on a 12 month lease.

Pricing pulled from ApartmentFinder and the property file, July 2026. Confirm current rates with the leasing office.

Net Effective Rent Calculation

The current special is 1 month free on a 12 month lease. Here’s what that means for your monthly cost using the daily multiplier method:

Example: 1BR at $749/month

  • Lease term: 12 months = 365 days
  • Free rent: 1 month = 30 days
  • Paying days: 365 – 30 = 335
  • Daily multiplier: 335 ÷ 365 = 0.9178
  • Net effective rent: $749 × 0.9178 = $687/month
  • Monthly savings: $749 – $687 = $62/month

That’s $62 less per month across the full lease compared to the listed price. They still look at the base rent ($749) when checking your income, not the net effective number.

All the Fees

Required Fees (Everyone Pays These):

Fee Amount Frequency
Application fee $50 per applicant One time
Admin fee $150 One time
Security deposit $500 (refundable) One time
Pest control $2 Monthly
Utility billing admin $2.11 Monthly
Valet trash $39 Monthly
Trash admin $7 Monthly
Renter’s insurance $18.75 Monthly
Gas/Water/Sewer/Stormwater Varies Monthly

Total fixed mandatory monthly fees: $68.86 on top of base rent, plus variable utility charges.

Optional Fees:

Fee Amount Frequency
Garage parking $15 Monthly
Reserved parking $5 Monthly
Pet fee (per pet) $300 One time
Pet rent (per pet) $25 Monthly
Late fee (after the 4th) 10% of base rent Per occurrence

Deposit alternative: Obligo is available if you want to skip the $500 security deposit upfront. Ask the leasing office about terms.

True Monthly Cost: What You’ll Actually Pay

Here’s what a realistic month looks like for a renter in the 1BR at $749 base with one dog:

Line Item Amount
Net effective rent (with 1 month free) $687
Mandatory monthly fees (pest, trash, utility admin, insurance) $68.86
Estimated gas/water/sewer/stormwater $75 – $125
Pet rent (1 dog) $25
Total estimated monthly cost $856 – $906

Move-in costs for this scenario:

  • Application fee: $50
  • Admin fee: $150
  • Security deposit: $500 (or Obligo alternative)
  • Pet fee: $300
  • First month rent: $749
  • Total move-in: approximately $1,749

That $749 listing price is really $856 to $906 a month once you add everything. Still below the Austin average. But it’s not $749.


Want to Compare This Against Other East Austin Options?

Tell me your budget, timeline, and what matters most. I’ll pull current specials from properties in the area so you can see how the numbers actually stack up.

Get Your Free Apartment Match →


Screening Criteria

Income Requirement

Flats at Wellington requires 3x monthly rent in total household income before taxes. That’s standard across most of Austin.

Base Rent Monthly Income Needed (3x) Annual Income Hourly Wage (40 hrs)
$749 $2,247 $26,964 ~$12.96
$799 $2,397 $28,764 ~$13.83
$849 $2,547 $30,564 ~$14.69
$899 $2,697 $32,364 ~$15.56
$1,099 $3,297 $39,564 ~$19.02

At $749 for a one bedroom, you need to earn about $13 an hour full time to qualify. That’s a low bar compared to most Austin apartments.

Harbor Group’s screening criteria (revised September 2025) says you have to send in your income paperwork “in an acceptable format” within 48 hours of them asking for it. They don’t spell out exactly which documents. In practice, most Austin apartments want two recent paystubs. Self-employed? Expect to show bank statements or a recent tax return. Harbor Group also uses Snappt to check whether your documents are real, so don’t submit anything altered.

If your income falls short, Harbor Group does accept guarantors. That can help you get past a conditional approval.

Credit Expectations

Here’s where it gets tricky. Harbor Group doesn’t publish a minimum credit score. Instead, they use SafeRent Solutions, a third party screening company that generates a “leasing risk score.” That score is based on your credit, rental history, criminal background, and other factors.

What that means in practice: there’s no clean number I can give you for a credit cutoff. Your approval depends on the algorithm, and the algorithm weighs multiple factors at once. Someone with a 620 credit score and clean rental history might get approved. And someone with a 650 and a past eviction might not.

What I can tell you based on how Harbor Group properties typically screen:

  • Clean credit (650+) and clean rental history: You’ll probably get approved without issues. Expect the standard $500 deposit.
  • Credit in the 580–649 range with no other red flags: Possible approval, but you might get “accepted with conditions,” meaning a higher deposit or additional requirements.
  • Below 570 or with rental history issues: Tougher odds. The SafeRent score will likely flag you. But Harbor Group does say they’ll look at your situation on its own. You can call 757-965-5416 to explain what happened if you’re denied or approved with conditions.

What Typically Gets You Denied

Let me be straight about what raises red flags in Harbor Group’s screening:

  • Recent eviction filings or eviction judgments on your record
  • Unpaid debt to previous landlords
  • Not enough income documentation
  • Felonies or misdemeanors requiring sex offender registration (Harbor Group says that’s an automatic no)
  • False information on the application (they will cancel and keep your fees)

Harbor Group’s own screening paperwork says “poor rental history may lead to an adverse decision.” That’s vague on purpose. It gives them room to say yes or no depending on the situation, but it also means you can’t predict the outcome the way you can at properties with hard cutoffs.

The Application Process

  1. Apply online through the property’s website or in person at the leasing office. $50 per applicant, non-refundable.
  2. Screening runs through SafeRent Solutions. They pull credit, rental history, and criminal background.
  3. Decision comes back as Accept, Accept with Conditions, or Denied. If conditional or denied, you’ll be told which factors hurt your score.
  4. Sign the lease within 3 days of approval (in person or phone) or 5 days if they mail you the approval.

If you’re approved, you’ll owe the admin fee ($150) and security deposit ($500) when you sign your lease.

A note on using a locator here: This property does not pay locator referral fees, which means I don’t earn a commission if you move in here. But I can still help you figure out whether this place makes sense for your situation before you spend $50 on an application. If it doesn’t, I know which nearby properties are a better fit and which ones will actually approve your profile.


Resident Reviews Decoded

Review Pattern Analysis

Theme Mentions Trend Sources
Dirty grounds, trash, broken glass 4+ mentions Older reviews (2021-2023); unclear if resolved Google, ForRent, ApartmentHomeLiving
Safety concerns (guns, police) 4+ mentions Concentrated in older reviews (~1 year ago on Google) Google, ForRent
Plumbing/sewage issues 3+ mentions Older reviews; sewage on walking paths reported in 2022 Google, ForRent
Management unresponsive (old mgmt) 4+ mentions Under old management; recent reviews say improving Google, ForRent
Maintenance failures 3+ mentions Older reviews; unclear if resolved Google, ForRent
Positive staff (Ashlyn) 2 mentions Recent (2-4 months ago) Google
New management improving things 2 mentions Recent (2-3 months ago) Google
Rodents 2 mentions Older reviews Google
Car related issues 5 mentions Spread across timeframes Google

Here’s what matters: I pulled reviews from Google (37 total), ForRent/Apartments.com (4 reviews), and ApartmentHomeLiving. ApartmentRatings and VeryApt had zero. The Yelp listing under the old name (Mueller Place) is marked closed. Small review pool, but the same complaints keep showing up everywhere.

Also worth knowing: this property used to be called Mueller Place and was managed by RPM Living. They changed the name to Flats at Wellington and brought in Harbor Group Management sometime in 2025 (the Yelp listings for Mueller Place closed in late 2025). That means most of the older reviews reflect the previous management team, not the current one.

The Split: Old Management (RPM Living) vs. New (Harbor Group)

This is the most important thing to understand about this property’s reviews. Under RPM Living, the reviews across multiple platforms were brutal. On Google, residents described gunshots near Building 5, loose dogs on the property, broken and boarded up windows, and water coming in during rain. Others reported spiders entering through gaps and maintenance requests that went nowhere. One reviewer sarcastically described the “amenities” as fleeing from loose dogs and bullets.

The ForRent/Apartments.com reviews add more detail. A February 2022 review described “constant plumbing issues, multiple instances of sewage leaking on walking paths.” That same reviewer said management “does not respond to calls, voicemails, or emails” and the leasing office door was locked when they were supposed to be open. An August 2021 review said the office wouldn’t answer phones or return emails. A December 2023 review described the property as “extremely dirty, trash everywhere” with “cops always called to the property.”

Then, within the last few months under Harbor Group, the tone shifted. One Google reviewer specifically praised “the new management company” for cleaning things up. Two separate reviews called out a leasing agent named Ashlyn for making the move in process smooth, patient, and thorough.

What This Means for You

New management can turn a property around. But it can also be a temporary push before things slide back. A few months of positive reviews isn’t enough to call it a trend. The building still has the same 1969 structure, the same plumbing, the same walls.

If you tour, pay attention to the grounds. Are the common areas clean? Is there stuff they’ve clearly let slide? Ask the leasing office directly about what’s changed and what’s still being worked on.

Management Response Pattern

Under the old management (RPM Living), the pattern was clear: a completely unresponsive office. Nobody picked up the phone. Emails were ignored. The leasing office door was locked when they were supposed to be open.

Under Harbor Group, there aren’t enough reviews yet to know if that’s changed. The positive reviews mention Ashlyn specifically, which at least tells you the leasing office is doing its job. But I checked Google, ForRent, Apartments.com, and ApartmentHomeLiving and couldn’t find a single owner response to any review. The Facebook page has 2 likes and almost no activity. That’s a red flag. Properties that respond to bad reviews tend to handle maintenance better too. If you tour, ask how they handle maintenance requests and how long it takes to get someone out.


The Uncomfortable Truth

No listing site will write this section. But I will. I’m not trying to kill the deal. I just want you to know exactly what you’re signing up for.

The Safety Concerns in Those Older Reviews Are Serious

Multiple reviews from about a year ago describe gunshots near Building 5 and cops showing up regularly. The Google review tags include “law enforcement” as a category with 2+ mentions. A separate review on ApartmentHomeLiving described cops being “always called to the property to handle disturbances.” New management may be addressing this. But these aren’t complaints about slow maintenance or thin walls. They’re about personal safety. Ask the leasing office what specific security changes have been made. The property does have access gates, but gates alone don’t solve this kind of problem.

1969 Construction Means 1969 Problems (Including Sewage)

The 2019 renovation gave units granite counters, updated appliances, and vinyl flooring. That’s cosmetic. The plumbing, electrical, soundproofing, and insulation are still from the original construction. A 2022 ForRent review described “constant plumbing issues, multiple instances of sewage leaking on walking paths.” Google reviews mention water coming in when it rains, smells coming through vents, and pest issues (rodents appear as a Google review tag). These aren’t just maintenance failures you can fix with a work order. They’re problems baked into a building this old. A LoopNet investment listing for this property said “unit interiors remain mostly untouched” beyond 7 of 86 units that were upgraded.

The pest control charge is $2/month, confirmed across ApartmentFinder and ForRent. That’s one of the lowest I’ve seen anywhere in Austin. Most properties charge $5 to $15. For a 1969 building where “rodents” shows up as a Google review tag, that gap is worth asking about. When you tour, ask how often they spray, who does it, and whether they treat common areas or just individual units on request.

The Screening Algorithm Is a Black Box

Harbor Group’s SafeRent screening system doesn’t give you a clear yes/no threshold. Unlike properties that say “we need a 580 credit score,” this system spits out one overall score. You won’t know where you stand until you’ve paid $50 and the algorithm runs. That matters because Harbor Group has been sued over how their AI screening tools handle housing voucher applications. If you’re using any form of rental assistance, ask the leasing office how those applications are handled.


Seen the Full Picture? Let’s Figure Out Your Next Step

Maybe Flats at Wellington works for you. Maybe you want to see what else is out there in this price range across East Austin. Either way, I can pull options based on your specific situation. No cost, no pressure.

Get Your Free Apartment Match →


FAQ

Does Flats at Wellington allow pets?

Yes. No weight limit, no breed restrictions. $300 one time fee plus $25/month per pet. The property listing says no cap on pet count, but Harbor Group’s corporate policy says 2 max. Confirm with the leasing office. Pet screening is required.

What credit score do I need for Flats at Wellington?

There’s no published minimum. Harbor Group uses SafeRent Solutions, which spits out a risk score based on your credit, rental history, and background. Scores above 650 with clean history generally get approved. Below 580 with other issues gets much harder.

What utilities are included in the rent?

None. You’ll pay for gas, water, sewer, and stormwater on top of rent. Those are variable. Fixed monthly fees add $68.86 to your base rent.

How much is the security deposit?

$500, refundable. An Obligo deposit alternative is available if you’d rather skip the upfront cost.

Does Flats at Wellington have in-unit washer and dryer?

Mostly no. Only a few of the A1 units (1BR, 712 sqft) have a washer/dryer connection. The rest don’t. The property has an onsite laundry room.

What’s the minimum lease length?

7 months. Most Austin apartments require 12 to 14. The 1 month free special needs a 12 month lease, so shorter terms likely won’t get the concession.

Is Flats at Wellington in a good location for commuting?

It’s decent. Downtown is about 5 miles south (12-15 minutes without traffic, 25-40 with). UT Austin is a similar distance. Samsung is about 12 miles east. The I-35 and US-290 access helps, but rush hour on I-35 is unpredictable. If you work from home, Windsor Park is quiet during the day and the fiber optic lines help. See our remote worker neighborhood guide for more. You’ll need a car either way.

When was Flats at Wellington built and last renovated?

Built in 1969. Renovated in 2019. The renovation updated the inside (granite counters, vinyl flooring, stainless appliances) but the structure, plumbing, and electrical are original.


The Bottom Line

Flats at Wellington’s pricing is genuinely cheap for this location. A one bedroom at $687 net effective and a two bedroom at $733, near Mueller in 78723, is hard to beat on paper. The pet policy is among the most flexible in Austin. The 7 month minimum lease gives you options most properties don’t.

The trade-off is a 1969 building with a rough recent history and a management team that’s only been in place for a few months.

This property makes sense if:

  • Keeping total monthly housing costs under $900 is your top priority
  • You have pets (especially larger breeds) and need a place that won’t turn you away
  • You want to be near East Austin without paying East Austin prices
  • You’re okay with older construction and limited common area amenities

This property doesn’t make sense if:

  • You need a washer/dryer in your unit (almost no units have connections)
  • Noise, safety history, or building age are dealbreakers for you
  • You want a pool, gym, or modern common areas
  • You’re using rental assistance and haven’t confirmed how the screening system handles it

My honest take: at this price, with this pet policy, in this location, Flats at Wellington fills a real gap. But go in with your eyes open. Tour Building 5 specifically. Ask about the security changes. Check the laundry room. Walk the grounds at night if you can. The price is right. Make sure the reality is too.


Need Help?

Option 1: Work with me. This property doesn’t pay locator fees, so I’m not making money if you move in here. But I can still help you compare it against other East Austin options that fit your budget. If Flats at Wellington makes sense, great. If not, I’ll steer you somewhere that does. My service costs you nothing.

Option 2: Go on your own. Call the leasing office directly at (737) 367-0769. The onsite manager is Sammy R. Office hours are Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM. Ask about the Hometown Hero discount if you’re military, a teacher, a nurse, or a first responder. And get the special in writing before you pay the application fee.

Just tell them “Ross Quade from Austin Apartment Team” referred you on your tour and application. Text me at 512-360-0852 when you apply so I can make sure everything’s on track.

Price:
$749-$1099
Address:
5800 Wellington Dr
Austin, TX 78723
Terms:
For Rent
Property Type:
Apartment
Year Built:
1969

Additional Features

Renovated 2019

Call 512-320-4599 for more details

Property Location